Should You Rent Out Your Old Home? Key Insights for New Homeowners
Explore the benefits and challenges of renting out your old home when buying a new one.

Have you ever wondered if you could turn your current home into a rental property when you move to a new place? It’s a question many homeowners ponder, and rightfully so. Turning your old home into a steady stream of rental income can sound enticing, but like most things in real estate and finance, it’s not a decision to be made lightly.
Weighing Your Options
Imagine this scenario: You’ve found your dream home and are ready to move. But instead of selling your old home, you consider renting it out. After all, it’s a promising way to generate passive income while slowly building wealth. But before you dive headfirst into this new venture, here are a few things to ponder:
- Understanding the Local Market: Check if your area has a strong rental market. This means understanding rental prices, vacancy rates, and finding out what tenants are really looking for.
- Managing Property as a Landlord: Are you prepared for the responsibilities of being a landlord? This includes everything from maintenance calls to tenant disputes. Consider hiring a property manager if you're short on time.
- Financial Implications: Evaluate your financial situation. Calculate the costs of owning and maintaining two homes and the taxes involved in rental income.
The Financial Side of Things
There's Kelsey, who started her rental journey with a small home in the suburbs. She was initially overwhelmed by the financial side of things, but after setting up a solid budget and tracking expenses meticulously, she found her groove. Here's a glimpse into Kelsey's financial strategy:

Kelsey relied on a budget planner to keep track of her expected income and expenses. She worked out the optimal rental price for her property by analyzing neighborhood trends and speaking with local realtors.
The Emotional Connection
There's also an emotional element you might not have considered. Letting strangers live in what was once your home can be a tough adjustment. Reflect on your feelings about this transition, as it could impact your experience as a landlord.
Putting the Plan into Action
Once you’re ready to rent out your old home, it’s crucial to market it effectively. Highlight its best features, take high-quality photos, and set a fair rental price. Being transparent and responsive to inquiries can also set the tone for a healthy landlord-tenant relationship.

As the saying goes, communication is key. When Kelsey rented her home, a simple chat with her first tenant led to smoother interactions and fewer misunderstandings. Content tenants are more likely to stay longer and pay rent on time.
Is Renting Out Your Old Home Right for You?
Renting out your old home can be a rewarding endeavor if approached with careful planning and consideration. It’s essential to weigh the Pros 👆 against the Cons 👇 before making your decision.

At the end of the day, only you can decide if this is the right path. How do you envision your future as a dual homeowner? Whether you choose to rent out or sell your old home, listening to your instincts and doing your homework will guide you to the best decision. What’s your take? Would you rent out your old home for extra income?